1. AALS and ISTE Standards

   People today like "new", especially when it is shiny or convenient, but people typically begin to grumble when "new" means confusion and misunderstanding. The latter is the "new experience" many school librarians across the country felt when the new AASL standards were released in 2018. After attending a conference, Courtney Lewis and her fellow independent school librarians decided to ban together to break down and understand the standards through the framework, outside sources, and conversations. They demonstrated the importance of collaboration in the role and success of school libraries and librarians (Lewis, 2019). 

    The same type of collaboration is a critical component that the AASL and ISTE standards provide the framework for learners and librarians. Both sets of standards place the students in the driver's seat during the inquiry phase and the importance of recognizing students' interests. AASL and ISTE understand the value of an environment that fosters and encourages learning and growth within each learner. The significance of learners making real-world connections so they can relate to the target skills of the learning standards is demonstrated throughout both standard sets. Self-feedback is another area in which learners are encouraged to evaluate and reflect on their learning and offer feedback to others within the AASL and the ISTE standards. 

    While AASL standards encourage a broad range of learning with a primary focus on information literacy, the ISTE emphasizes digital literacy. The infographics below provide an example of how each standard is set up. AASL standards use short phrases for their competencies, while the ISTE uses an objective sentence approach, much like state education standards. Another critical difference between the two standard sets involves inclusion and the amount of emphasis each places on this shared foundation. When referring to the lack of standards from the ISTE under the "Include" foundation on the crosswalk (AASL, 2018) for the standard sets, Lewis (2019) stated, "(it) demonstrates school librarians' emphasis on issues of diversity and inclusivity in our work." The AASL standards show that librarians play a significant role in the information skills and more of learners. Still, it is also essential to understand that the way learners gather, send, and receive information has changed drastically in the last decades. This awareness creates a bridge between the AASL and ISTE standards that every librarian should crossover and connect with daily. Using these two standard sets as supporting documents for each other rather than competing is the only way for librarians to truly provide learners with well-balanced information literacy instruction. 

                  

          (American Association of School Librarians, 2018)            (International Society for Technology in Education, 2016)

    

References

AASL standards crosswalk future ready. American Association of School Librarians. (2018). 

        Retrieved June 21, 2022, from https://standards.aasl.org/wp-

        content/uploads/2018/08/180828-aasl-standardscrosswalk-future-ready.pdf

American Association of School Librarians. (2018). Shared foundations: Engage.

        [Infographic]. American Association of School Librarians. 

        https://standards.aasl.org/project/foundations/.

International Society for Technology in Education. (2016). I am a digital age learner. 

        [Infographic]. International Society for Technology in Education. https://info.iste.org/iste-

        student-standards-transform-the-classroom-            

        poster_ga=2.104771720.987667400.1655769278-246135604.1655769278.

Lewis, C. (2019). “Collaborating to communicate.” Knowledge Quest. (47)5, 36-43. 

 

 

 

 

Comments

  1. I agree that these standards can be used together to reach learning goals. While there are some differences, there is also a lot of overlap, and the standards address many of the same areas and skills. Librarians can work with teachers to plan lessons and learning activities that address both sets of standards at the same time.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You are right -- our world has changed. In a video by Chris Stanger (referenced on my blog), he notes the importance of teachers' understanding that education has changed. We no longer live in a book/note learning world. In today's modern world, students learn from digital media far more than printed text. Students should also be able to identify reliable information as well as disseminate unreliable details. I find the crosswalk document provided by the American Association of School Librarians a good starting point as we learn to navigate both the AASL and ISTE standards. Take a look at: https://standards.aasl.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/180828-aasl-standards-crosswalk-iste.pdf.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This was very beautifully written. You make a great point when you highlight the fact that a change or shift in anything is scary, but especially to educators. What Courtney Lewis and her colleagues did was an excellent example of collaboration for a greater cause. I also believe that collaboration is key when attempting to understand and implement the AASL and ISTE standards. They are both great tools and building a thorough understanding of them and how they work together is essential to the implementation process. I also believe that both of the standards should be a daily aspect of every school librarian's instruction.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I also noticed that when faced with a learning opportunity (the new AASL standards being published), that Lewis formed a group of fellow librarians and they sat down to collaborate and learn together. They were highlighting the Foundation of Include seamlessly. They balanced each other's perspectives in their learning community. They also modeled quality gathering and organizing of new information, showing their mastery of the Curate Foundation.
    Not being a current teacher myself, I don't have the perspective that you have laid out about how these standards may or may not mesh with your current state teaching standards. I think these differences highlight the value of the librarian and library in the learning life of the students.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I like the inclusion of self-feedback and real-world connections that is present in the AASL and ISTE standards, as you mentioned. I think that too often, students lose interest in learning because they do not see the relevance in the subject matter. I also think that the similarities as well as the differences between these two standards work well together, supporting similar sills and learning goals and highlighting different approaches to achieve them (in the case of the ISTE standards, using digital tools and related skill sets).

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment